800-465-4656 [email protected]

I use AI every single day.

It drafts. It researches. It analyzes data. It helps me think through strategy. It’s a brilliant back-office partner.

We use AI all day at CPLUS. Just never to answer a client who’s stuck.

That’s because there’s one job I don’t think AI should be doing by itself: handling your customers when something goes wrong.

Here’s why.

My Dropbox saga

The other day, a set of folders vanished from my Dropbox. Gone. Poof.

The weird part? One of my team members could see them just fine. I couldn’t.

So I did what we all do. I clicked “Help.” And I got a chatbot.

We went back and forth. And back. And forth. Have you tried this? Have you cleared your cache? Here’s a help article. Here’s another help article. Is there anything else I can help you with?

Yes. The thing I came here for.

After an excruciating stretch, I typed the magic words: “I want to speak to a human.”

And this is where things turned around.

I gave them my cell number. They called back almost instantly. I waited a minute or two. Then I was connected with an absolutely lovely customer service rep.

She cracked a joke right off the bat. My shoulders dropped about three inches. She was warm. Engaged. Professional. She knew her stuff cold.

She solved the problem in minutes.

Here’s the part that surprised me. By the time I hung up, I’d forgotten the bot entirely. My trust in Dropbox went up, not down.

One great human erased twenty minutes of robot frustration.

That’s the power of people.

The golden rule of customer service

Here’s my rule of thumb.

Don’t do to your customers what you don’t want done to you.

Be honest. Do you enjoy being stuck in a loop with a bot when something’s broken? When you’re stressed? When you’re on a deadline?

No? Me neither.

So why would your customers want it?

When things are working, nobody calls you. Customers reach out when something’s gone wrong. That’s exactly the moment they’re frustrated, anxious, or confused. And that’s exactly the moment they need a person.

A bot can answer a question. Only a human can lower someone’s blood pressure.

The door, not the wall

To be fair, Dropbox got the most important part right. The bot didn’t trap me. When I asked for a human, I got one. Fast.

That’s the right way to think about it.

AI can open the door. A person should walk the customer through it.

Let the bot handle the simple stuff. Collect the details. Route the call. Then get out of the way.

The trouble starts when the bot turns into a wall. When “talk to a person” is buried three menus deep. When the bot keeps sending help articles to someone who has already read them.

That’s when you lose people.

Let’s run the numbers

I’m an accountant. I can’t help myself.

Say you run a business with 200 customers, each worth $5,000 a year. That’s $1,000,000 in revenue.

Now say your chatbot frustrates just 5% of them enough to quietly walk away. That’s 10 customers.

10 × $5,000 = $50,000 a year. Gone.

And that’s just year one. Lost customers don’t come back next year either. Plus they tell their friends.

Now compare that to the cost of a friendly, knowledgeable part-time support person. In many markets, that’s less than the revenue you just lost. And that person keeps customers. Maybe even grows them.

(Illustrative numbers. Plug in your own. The math rarely favours the wall.)

A bot looks cheap on the expense line. It can cost you a lot on the revenue line.

Where AI shines. And where people do.

Use AI for:

  • Backend systems and workflows
  • Drafting agreements and documents
  • Research and analysis
  • Design work
  • Strategy and brainstorming
  • Crunching data
  • Triage: simple questions, gathering details, routing to the right person

Keep humans for:

  • Solving customer problems
  • Handling complaints
  • Calming frustrated people
  • Building trust and loyalty
A quick gut-check for your business

Ask yourself:

  1. Can a customer reach a human in under two minutes? If not, fix that first.
  2. Is “talk to a person” easy to find? Don’t bury it. Customers notice.
  3. Have you tried your own support line lately? Be the customer for a day. Brace yourself.
  4. Are your people trained to be warm, not just accurate? Knowledge solves the problem. Warmth keeps the customer.
  5. Is your bot a door or a wall? If it helps people get to a human faster, great. If it keeps them away from one, rethink it.
The bottom line

Systems are wonderful. On the back end.

But where your business meets your customers, everyone wants the same thing. A real person who is professional, friendly, and knows their stuff.

That lady at Dropbox didn’t just fix my folders. She fixed my opinion of the whole company.

No bot has ever done that for me.

Thanks kindly for reading…